Testing for sure.
I could use the metal floating shelf brackets from Rockler. However, they depend on being able to drill a 3" plus hole into the wall studs. I can certainly get a bit long enough. However, ensuring that these holes are exactly 90 degrees to the wall surface seems a little iffy. I'm sure there are ways to do this, but it just seems like, if there is even a very small difference off 90 degrees, especially if the error is downward, problems will result.
The dominos are assured to be straight in both pieces of wood. Drilling a pilot hole into the wall for screws to mount the back piece to the wall doesn't seem to require quite the same level of accuracy and precision. Even very close should get the piece attached to the wall mounted flat.
Plus, after talking the whole thing over with my wife, we decided to just not do the shelves. Enough oak, maple, or cherry to do three 5' long shelves would require 30 board feet of wood; either 8/4 live edge slabs or boards or 4/4 glued together. At today's prices with my current access to good quality lumber that could be $600+. It doesn't seem worth it. Add $20 apiece for maybe up to 9 metal brackets or the cost of a 14mm Domino cutter plus the cost of 14 mm dominos (I don't own a 14 mm bit or dominos.) the cost isn't worth it. We just decided to find other ways to fill a blank wall that was created by a remodel; maybe with a nice sofa table size table below and artwork on the wall. I am a turner and have more bowls than I know what to do with and my wife is a polymer clay artist (actually a multi-talented artist) who has a number of wall hangings and other art.