I’ve owned many handgun holsters from several different manufacturers over the years. The most thoughtfully designed, and the best (in my opinion) are the Simply Rugged holsters.
Unlike the other premium holster manufacturers who hand form the fully assembled leather holster while it is still wet, to precisely show the outline of the underlying gun, Simply rugged has a more general shape telegraphed through the leather. I suspect that instead of hand working the leather, they use a vacuum bag to form it while still wet.
By comparison, the Simply Rugged holsters are functional right out of the box. The DeSantis (and most others) are generally so tightly ensconced that it is impossible to draw the gun from the holster without some work by the buyer.
Also, the retention aspect of the Simply Rugged holsters remain the same for many years. While the highly tooled versions from other manufacturers gradually loosen and ultimately get too loose.
Kydex will not break-in. The fit has to be perfect from the outset. If you impress the Kydex too tightly to the shape of the knife, I suspect that the knife will be nearly impossible to extract. The major manufacturers include screws that will offer some adjustment.
I think I would go for the Simply Rugged approach and not make the sheath perfectly conform to the knife. The sheath, ideally will allow easy access without the knife falling out on its own.
However, my experience is entirely at the user end of the equation, with only that one attempt by my friend to make a sheath (with me in assistance).
So take my suggestions with that lack of maker-experience in mind.
Compare:
Simply Rugged

DeSantis Leather
